Sonic: Lost World occasionally seems really good. It looks lovely, some of the earlier levels are pretty fun to speed through (they flip between 2D and 3D like Sonic Generations) and he doesn’t awkwardly smooch any humans like in the 2006 abomination.
But for every section where you think things might look up, there are two or three that make you wish he was roadkill.
There’s a hefty Mario Galaxy influence in the 3D levels, what with the spherical worlds you explore. Mario controlled perfectly, though, so you never felt like you could lose control of the little guy. Sonic? He’s a recalcitrant goon. More than once you’ll be tempted to chuck the gamepad at the TV screen. Sonic will automatically home in on stuff, even when you don’t want him to.
You could be aiming towards a bounce pad, but the game decides you want to attack the spiky enemy behind you, leading to the inevitable loss of all your rings and, of course, death. Then there’s the wall running and parkour elements, which, again, will sometimes not do what you want them to do and you’ll inexorably fall into some abyss. Or lava. There’s always lava.
The 2D levels fare no better either. Some of them drag on and on, and are filled with awkward stop/start sections that kill any momentum the game might be building.
Basically, with Rayman Legends being so good and the superb looking Super Mario 3D World’s release imminent, it’s harder than ever to tolerate yet another stultifyingly average, underperforming Sonic title.
It’s a shame, because there are parts that are genuinely excellent, like one level where Sonic is a giant snowball; awkward controls, a clump of dreadful levels (including insta-death grind-rail nonsense) and some horrendous, unfunny boss encounters, though, make you wish he’d genuinely get lost.
Game completed in 11 hours.